Some thoughts from a guy who read 0 posts itt
Getting "there's a third party" from literal standard role PMs is hilariously stupid. Every role PM should read like these ones unless your setup is open or you explicitly want to hand out more information about the setup (which is fine if that's what you're looking to do).
Scum were slightly underpowered - it wouldn't have mattered this game because they went and got themselves killed but they did need a bit more of something
Scum getting eliminated asap was about as poor of an outcome as possible for the balance of this game, it would have been much more interesting otherwise. That's unfortunate.
I completely forgot about the existence of safeclaims LOL
I have no idea why anyone would claim to be a neutral with a wincon which could clearly steal the win from town