Jump to content


┬╗Retired Staff
  • Content count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won


Everything posted by JC.

  1. how did you come up with the plot for this? why was i the bad guy what were the different ways i was going to die
  2. francis' first post in the neighborhood was "who is the other mason" part of the reason i dodged the questions was actually because i was super paranoid that Francis was a Lie Detector or that there was some kind of Trigger Word ability that could out me if i used the word 'Mason'
  3. I didn't have any issues with the game, especially as I could get feedback from Francis unlike the rest of the players in the thread. But, I'm starting to think Mafia just isn't a very fun game. There is someone frustrated nearly 100% of the time. The games take forever, which means that people who get invested feel worse if they end up losing, especially if they have a plan to win that gets ruined by either their townmates not listening or their scummates outing themselves. In the end, we're all probably making our lives worse for ourselves and for others by choosing to play. The good parts don't really outweigh the negatives fmpov. p.p.s. MVP in 3 out of my last 3 games. retiring as champion
  4. Sage - you joked around with me both in the neighborhood and in the game thread. it should be Non Alignment Indicative, but people might read into it. i enjoyed it, obviously, but others might not in the future. p.s. jc in the game: has 0 votes on him at all ever jc in the postgame: everyone talking about how i was definitely scum
  5. the implied part of talking about francis at start of day 2 was meant to be "i think scum did not kill me because they are going all-in for the mislynch on my mason partner" but i only put that part in the neighborhood QT you're right that it was a bad post though @rei im not sure which part specifically you are referring to. i definitely tunnel as both alignments (e.g. the 2 games in a row i went after 2k for wanting to let malcolm control the lynch), but the stuff about Walia being town was completely manufactured from Francis; if i were town, i actually would have voted Walia in my first post because i see scum complain about their roles all the time
  6. It's fair to criticize me for sticking onto Soph + Haz without really talking about other players, but I don't think it is scummy to have a team that early in the thread like people were saying during the game. Yeah, it was only page 2, but how many times has rei found something scummy and linked a partner on some seemingly innocuous post page 1? I remember it just recently with the flacko + jericho scum game.
  7. that assumes i would play the same way without the mason claim, which may not be true i probably would have ended up voting for Francis myself, as he started the game by giving town reads on everybody and then swapped to scum reading everybody by the end of the day
  8. to be fair, i said I knew Francis was town and that I would die if he voted for me, both of which are true as scum as well i really wasn't trying to create that much confusion when i made my claim, but i let it go on for that long because i was scum
  9. wait you were an insane cop? that is rough : / in this specific instance, it wouldnt have been too bad because Soph would come back, Francis would skip the NK, and then you would know and be able to deduce the scum team, but i am definitely 100% against hosts providing inaccurate info
  10. im the worst player of all time meant to vote soph as evidenced by the rest of my post
  11. wait... @SageRhapsody i think that's majority
  12. the way i see it, soph has to die today almost definitely lying about ability and trying to lynch despite my claim with lyncher if not, and soph is town, lyncher skips night phase and soph comes back, putting us in same position with a confirmed town. at that point it is Tyranno and haz by poe vote lyncher
  13. We can't verify that at all, while we could have if you claimed yesterday. What was your reasoning for softing that you had a role you wanted to use?
  14. i think the team is probably still just soph/haz, but not voting yet ...or, actually, since there wasnt a lylo announcement, maybe we're dealing with something stupid like Survivor + Serial Killer?
  15. as far as i could tell from backreading, rei's only real read was on Francis. Walia started on Soph, but switched to Francis later in the day. im still not voting for francis, though. for everyone else, as far as i can tell, the case is "not active in the thread", but he gave reads, came back to change vote near eod, and continued to communicate with me. lynching him is game throwing fmpov
  16. there are a lot of posts, who can blame Sage for missing a post by Sage?
  17. im not lynching Francis and rei was my 3rd choice so i guess unvote vote rei his arguments today have included variants of "page 2 is too early to catch scum" and "having town reads is wifom"
  18. ebwop i actually dont see rei's vote on The Lyncher in the thread, but i copied that part from Sage's vote count earlier
  19. unofficial vote count The Lynchers (2) - rei, hazmah Sophocles (2) - JC., The Lyncher TheGoldenTyranno (1) - Sophocles Not Voting: walia, TheGoldenTyranno i was really excited to see the flavour this game. hoping for a full Light Novel at eod.
  20. If the first part of this was a joke about ignoring users, I missed it, but I did not like either part of this post. This post doesn't make any sense to me, am I misreading it? "JC and Francis probably aren't masons or scum, but do know each other's alignments."
  21. to be clear, The Lyncher's play of 'make quota and Haha React' is not part of our strategy here, but I'm trying to make the best of my situation. i think that's probably why things seem weird?
  22. please use your brains i stated with confidence Lyncher was not scum and then posted reads i claimed to be from him his vote is not on me, when it would be a dunk if he saw me coming into the thread lying and misrepresenting the situation. if you really think we are 9000 iq alpha mastermind scum, i cant stop you, but how about we do literally anything else instead?
  23. I'm going to die in a lot of different ways, perhaps modkill included, because you're the only girl I see. uwu
  24. Don't let the new year distract you from the fact that SageRhapsody was supposed to provide flavour roughly 19 hours ago.