Jump to content


  • Content count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won


Everything posted by Sophocles

  1. Things are heating up over here... https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=2d3 - Standard rules - Scum will use discord to communicate - 48/24 phases (I thought this worked well last game, I may occasionally cut a few hours from night phases for practicalities so it might be more like 20 hours) - Random lynch on ties - 4 post quota - No majority D1, Majority starts the next phase 1. Wunter 2. Faint 3. Tyranno 4. KimJongUnderballs 5. 6. 7. 8. 9.
  2. TGT's Vanilla Mafia[Town wins]

    You played very well imo. You didn't know the meta or any of the players but you stuck your neck out anyway and made well thought out posts. Not a lot of people here would have done the same in your shoes. Props.
  3. Mafia New Games Hosting Queue

    I wouldn't mind running another Matrix 14. Looked like a fun set-up
  4. TGT's Vanilla Mafia[Town wins]

    Solid performance buddy
  5. TGT's Vanilla Mafia[Town wins]

    I'm being frank here but the fact that Jazz gets super personal, furious and borderline ruins the fun of the game half the times he's close to being mislynched as town makes it a lot easier to catch him as scum. PlantTheWalia
  6. TGT's Vanilla Mafia[Town wins]

    this is bad reasoning, we're not in lylo, scum wouldn't look for a hammer.
  7. TGT's Vanilla Mafia[Town wins]

    Definitely kill Jazz, trust me on this.
  8. TGT's Vanilla Mafia[Town wins]

    It says so literally in the post you quoted; after the horrendous post by Solstice right before. Changing your opinion on someone in response to their posts isn't doing a 180 lol, it's town play.
  9. TGT's Vanilla Mafia[Town wins]

    Apart from Malcolm making some ominous posts there were no responses to Solstice's claim yet. Jazz calling it out as bs means he gets to take charge of the conversation.
  10. TGT's Vanilla Mafia[Town wins]

  11. TGT's Vanilla Mafia[Town wins]

    Line 1: Yeah exactly. Saves a NK. Line 2: Malcolm wanted to lynch Jazz for half of D1 lol. Additionally, if 1 scum gets lynched he effectively becomes a cop. The scenario where scum is so comfortable as to not kill tracker exists, but is fringe. I also don't think that's how the meta works here or how scum would reason.
  12. TGT's Vanilla Mafia[Town wins]

    Town Jazz: 'I could have gone for the safer play but I had to make a last minute decision, so I kept my vote on Solstice' Scum Jazz: 'I could have gone for the safer play and unvoted, but I had to make a last minute decision so I doubled down to make sure Solstice got lynched.' There is direct incentive for ScumJazz to make sure a lynch on Solstice goes through. How much of a risk is it really when I'm the only person actually pointing this out and people are bringing Wifom 'Well he wouldn't do this obviously anti-town action as scum, he's likely town' into this?
  13. TGT's Vanilla Mafia[Town wins]

    Again, in this scenario scum is obligated to either kill the claimed doc or leave both power roles alive. That's 2 confirmed townies and tracking 'til Lylo. There was no rush at all to kill Solstice.
  14. TGT's Vanilla Mafia[Town wins]

    No, I see your point, I'm saying your core contention that there is no incentive to lynch the power role for scum is wrong. The set-up had a tracker and a doc who claimed. There is no role blocker. So unless they want to give limittless tracks to town, killing tracker is priority. Which requires taking out doc first. Either way, Solstice was going to be dead today - either by a lynch or a NK. Eliminating the doc without having to expend a NK on it is a net positive. That way they can NK a townie that's being townread and/or contributing a lot, instead of spending another night killing the tracker. That you eliminate any chance of tracker getting a track off is just added bonus.
  15. TGT's Vanilla Mafia[Town wins]

    You knew you and malcolm were town, that ties it up to 4-4. You needed one townie showing up to switch it to Paraliel. Fair enough if you end up not doing that because no one's on, but you didn't even bring it up. That's either a major screw up or you're scum. Second line doesn't even make sense, yeah no shit in the world where you're town, scum doesn't need to do a thing because you and Malcolm fucked town in the ass. Don't diffuse blame here, you were active. Your play was downright anti-town.
  16. TGT's Vanilla Mafia[Town wins]

    Duk3star not helping his case at all btw with the hard defense of Jazz
  17. TGT's Vanilla Mafia[Town wins]

    The rare LVP Malcolm game btw that claim did nothing?
  18. TGT's Vanilla Mafia[Town wins]

    Paraliel is town, Faint is town. Jazz is scum. Remaining scummer is between Duk3star Walia and Wunter.
  19. TGT's Vanilla Mafia[Town wins]

    Repeat, Jazz is not a policy lynch. He should've recognised that lynching Solstice, in the absence of a counterclaim and with Malcolm claiming, was the wrong play. Instead he did not even consider this and doubled down.
  20. TGT's Vanilla Mafia[Town wins]

    ??? Why would you not just want to take out the doc then NK the tracker? If you don't you have to spend a NK on a doc you could've lynched, then NK the tracker next night. Now they've eliminated the two power roles at the start of D2. Town Jazz would've turned off the Solstice lynch and looked for a swap last minute. Yeah it was a bad claim and bad play from Solstice but after Malcolm claimed tracker it was obviously the correct play not to lynch Solstice.
  21. TGT's Vanilla Mafia[Town wins]

    vote Jazz
  22. TGT's Vanilla Mafia[Town wins]

    gg go next
  23. TGT's Vanilla Mafia[Town wins]

    Wunter is being suppremely unhelpful, should keep a close eye on him.
  24. TGT's Vanilla Mafia[Town wins]

    Para voting Solstice at the stage he did would be pretty wanton, likewise the Solstice analysis of Paraliel would raise more suspicion than anything if either flipped scum.
  25. TGT's Vanilla Mafia[Town wins]

    That's a bit too early to say but he's not a very good lynch and the number of people voting him/calling him a good lynch without giving reasons makes me very wary.