Honestly the top overall player on the site is probably Malcolm given he has the best overall game, but thats partly because
1. He generally gets an initial pass as ppl dont want to kill him early (this is both an indictment on the community and a credit to his town game being good enough to warrant that.) I srsly think cop could claim with a n0 red check on him an ppl will probably kill the unccd cop over Malcolm.
2. Because of one, we give him a pass on things that if other players pulled them we'd autolynch them. This isn't an indictment on anyone but more like Malcolm just policying out our desire to punish him for play that isn't always transparent. We've compensated and found other ways to deal with it.
After that the next best is probably rei. He has the best town game by far and his scum game is at least functional if not above average (which isnt saying much given scum games in general on dg).
Confuse rei would probably be next if he still plays. Tbh he would probably be the #1 player because he really knows how to manipulate the social element of the game probably better than anyone here, but he doesnt play often. One thing he probably understands better than anyone is perception and timing. Even if he gets caught, he doesn't flip out because he is able to take a step back and look at thing as if he didnt have perfect info and react accordingly. As for timing, he knows when to push and when to hold back. He knows how to wait until town is more receptive to his lynch idea and/or when his town platform is strongest to push. Those are probably the hardest elements of this game to master and his grasp on them is strong.
Just my 2cents