Arbitrary Mafia Power Rankings

[slickz 4308]

S Tier 

rei 
Confuse rei 

Malcolm 

A Tier   

Francis J Underwood 
 

B+ Tier   

PSK

Zappdos
LFN

Allen 
 

B- Tier

ZeroPassion

Nelrick

JC 

2k17
Sophocles

Jazz

Mark

Markus
The Antagonist

Winter Multi

Solstice

Gemstone Mine

The B3ast

 

C Tier  

Kahu

Mascis 

Silver 

 

F Tier 

Wunterslaus 

Broken Brilliance

Tyranno

 

 

 

Tier Explanation:  

 

 

 

S Tier - Can single-handedly win games on their own, blow games open at a moments notice, and demand respect every phase of the game. Can play either scum or town optimally.

 

A Tier - Can also single-handedly win games, but can be outshined or manipulated when playing with S tier players. Can also play scum or town optimally. 

 

B+ Tier - All perfectly viable players that can adequately post and work together to win games. Have a strong town or scum game but usually not both.  

 

B- Tier- Also perfectly viable. Have a few shortcomings that keep them from B+ but frequently make good posts, reads, and plays. Will occasionally float.

 

C Tier - Can make headscratching plays but make good posts and reads sporadically. Need to be paired with higher tiered players to make an impact. Frequently float. 

 

F Tier - Makes damaging or confusing plays often.  Harmful to faction they are a part of. Seldom makes good decisions and usually don't see the bigger picture.

 

 

 

Changes: 

06/29/17 - Split B tier into B+ and B- tiers with explanation. Added MBA, LFN, and Juan for nostalgic purposes. Added numerical rankings.  

 

07/06/17 - Removed Digbick from Rankings. Moved iSlickz into B+ tier spot 11 and Jazz to B- tier spot 13. Moved PSK up from 6 to 5. Moved The Antagonist down to 15. Moved Markus up to 19.  Moved Winter Multi down to 24 and Zero Passion up to 22. Moved Mascis up to 25 and Wunterslaus down to 28. 

 

07/25/17 - Moved Wunterslaus to F tier. Moved Nelrick up several spots and Mark down several spots. Moved Winter Multi up 2 spots. Moved Jazz to 11.  

 

08/08/17 - Added Paraliel, Japenese Goblin, TFJ, Broken Brilliance, and Cunning Mastermind to rankings. Several minor tweaks based on WWE Mafia.  

 

09/06/17 - Removed inactive players. Removed myself. Removed numerical rankings. Changes reflect previous two games.

[+Silver]

[+TheGoldenTyranno]

I'm confused why did you place the tier that contains the objectively best players on the forum below S-Tier? 

[slickz 4308]

Just now, TheGoldenTyranno said:

I'm confused why did you place the tier that contains the objectively best players on the forum below S-Tier? 

This is a subjective tier list, you know how those work right?

[+Silver]

idg the point of this.

 

is this a dick measuring contest or something to trash the lower tier players

 

 

[+TheGoldenTyranno]

1 minute ago, iSlickz said:

This is a subjective tier list, you know how those work right?

Well, whatever you call it all I see is a bunch of malarky. 

 

Vote iSlickz

[+Silver]

also im offended im worse than kahu

[+Silver]

also

 

i love kahu

 

 

[slickz 4308]

6 minutes ago, TheGoldenTyranno said:

Well, whatever you call it all I see is a bunch of malarky. 

 

Vote iSlickz

Explain

[+TheGoldenTyranno]

1 minute ago, iSlickz said:

Explain

It reminds me of one of my town read lists. Need I say more?

[+TheGoldenTyranno]

I mean just look at that overcrowded b section. Does b section mean something like, "I don't hate you but you really ain't that good at mafia"?

[+TheGoldenTyranno]

1 minute ago, TheGoldenTyranno said:

I mean just look at that overcrowded b section. Does b section mean something like, "I don't hate you but you really ain't that good at mafia"?

At least that would mean you're being sorta honest. 

[slickz 4308]

S Tier - Can single-handedly win games on their own, blow games open at a moments notice, and demand respect every phase of the game. Can play either scum or town optimally.

 

A Tier - Can also single-handedly win games, but can be outshined or manipulated when playing with S tier players. Can also play scum or town optimally. 

 

B Tier - All perfectly viable players that can adequately post and work together to win games. Have a strong town or scum game but usually not both. 

 

C Tier - Can make headscratching plays but make good posts and reads sporadically. Needs to be paired with higher tiered players to make an impact. Tends to float. 

 

F Tier - Makes damaging or confusing plays often.  Harmful to faction they are a part of. Seldom makes good decisions and usually don't see the bigger picture. 

[+Silver]

31 minutes ago, iSlickz said:

S Tier - Can single-handedly win games on their own, blow games open at a moments notice, and demand respect every phase of the game. Can play either scum or town optimally.

 

A Tier - Can also single-handedly win games, but can be outshined or manipulated when playing with S tier players. Can also play scum or town optimally. 

 

B Tier - All perfectly viable players that can adequately post and work together to win games. Have a strong town or scum game but usually not both. 

 

C Tier - Can make headscratching plays but make good posts and reads sporadically. Needs to be paired with higher tiered players to make an impact. Tends to float. 

 

F Tier - Makes damaging or confusing plays often.  Harmful to faction they are a part of. Seldom makes good decisions and usually don't see the bigger picture. 

 

[slickz 4308]

That was a good play lol stop being salty

[Flacko 2143]

HOW DARE YOU PUT MARK IN THE SAME TIER WITH ME

[»ACP]

Ctrl+F for Harima: No results

 

Shame on you, iSlickz.

[+scuzzlebutt]

where am i

[2K18 256]

Are they in order?

[+scuzzlebutt]

Quote

 

SS Tier

MMF

 

S Tier 
rei 
Confuse rei 

A Tier   

Malcolm 

Francis J Underwood

 

ftfy

[+scuzzlebutt]

[+Malcolm]

switch your name back to iSalty

[+Malcolm]

nice list! i do not share your view on many players but i respect your right to an opinion!

[+Gemstone Mine]

fuck this mafia section.

 

Even got malcolm to play nice with others.

[+Gemstone Mine]

#fuckthepolice