Brandis72 40 Posted October 28 Ash flipped town and had 1 strong read in dya ...Dya was one of the only people who didn't vote for rei despite him being an obvious lynch for scum. (and dya took quite a bit of personal risk for deviating; this is honestly taking things too far for a scum gambit) Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Brandis72 40 Posted October 28 1 hour ago, JC. said: Auri/Faint for scum are fairly unexplored this game; what reasoning drew you to those conclusions? Auri's plays are consistently + ev for scum and I've seen absolutely nothing to make me believe they're just wrong town. Faint hasn't done as much so I may still give him the benefit of the doubt... for now. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Brandis72 40 Posted October 28 Will post more later. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
773 202 LUNA 2908 Posted October 28 3 minutes ago, Brandis72 said: Will post more later. delicious Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
+Jazz 5488 Posted October 28 Vote Count: flacko - (2) Walia, Woawa Dyachei - (1) Faint Sage - (1) TGT Not Voting: (9) audio, auri, Brandis, Dyachei, flacko, haz, JC, Moxies, Sage Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
BuildTheWalia 285 Posted October 28 2 hours ago, Brandis72 said: Auri's plays are consistently + ev for scum and I've seen absolutely nothing to make me believe they're just wrong town. Faint hasn't done as much so I may still give him the benefit of the doubt... for now. Can you specifically elaborate on auri? And Faint has barely posted at all, why read him above others? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Moxies 12 Posted October 28 ive i have to choose 3 it be flaccko dya and brandis sage Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
»JC. 5281 Posted October 28 33 minutes ago, Moxies said: ive i have to choose 3 it be flaccko dya and brandis sage That is 4, and you haven't provided any reason why. Try again pls. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Moxies 12 Posted October 28 i dont really have any opinions everyone else has made solid enough arguements that i agree with that im willing to go with that Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
dyachei 20 Posted October 28 24 minutes ago, Moxies said: i dont really have any opinions everyone else has made solid enough arguements that i agree with that im willing to go with that so what are their reasons for thinking any of those 4. I want to know what you're thinking at all. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
BuildTheWalia 285 Posted October 28 54 minutes ago, Moxies said: i dont really have any opinions everyone else has made solid enough arguements that i agree with that im willing to go with that The thing is that 3 of the people in the game are still mafia, so you need to evaluate everyone's arguments based on that. Who specifically do you agree with to make the names you listed your proposed team? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Faint 5950 Posted October 28 21 hours ago, dyachei said: my team is one of walia/brandis (think brandis more likely), flacko, +1 This is big flags for walia/dya team right here Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Faint 5950 Posted October 28 "Hi guys this is my scum team plus 1 but probably not this guy lol though he is suspicious maybe so if one of us flips then I told you so!" Now to find the 3rd Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Faint 5950 Posted October 28 I still dont like sages post at all and I'm very concerned that @JC. would rather soft threaten to vote me for using common sense, than discuss sage in more detail Fwiw jc is reading town but hes reading very bad town right now Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
dyachei 20 Posted October 28 49 minutes ago, Faint said: "Hi guys this is my scum team plus 1 but probably not this guy lol though he is suspicious maybe so if one of us flips then I told you so!" Now to find the 3rd you're misunderstanding me pretty severely. I think they are both wolfy, but brandis is wolfier and they are never on the same team. If you think that means I'm teamed with walia, you need to figure out how to get back to square 1. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
dyachei 20 Posted October 28 Here's a reads list - they aren't in order within the tiers Town JC Town lean Tony Sage Claims: Woawa TGT Nullish Faint Scum Lean Auri moxies Scum Walia Brandis Flacko Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
+TheGoldenTyranno 602 Posted October 29 1 hour ago, dyachei said: Here's a reads list - they aren't in order within the tiers Town JC Town lean Tony Sage Claims: Woawa TGT Nullish Faint Scum Lean Auri moxies Scum Walia Brandis Flacko u forgot Hazmah and Flacko technically has a claim of sorts Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
+TheGoldenTyranno 602 Posted October 29 2 hours ago, Faint said: This is big flags for walia/dya team right here Is ur preference to off miss Dya first if this scum team holds up? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
dyachei 20 Posted October 29 21 minutes ago, TheGoldenTyranno said: u forgot Hazmah and Flacko technically has a claim of sorts hazmah is lock town Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
773 202 LUNA 2908 Posted October 29 I think now is as good a time as any to claim. I am MerchBot - once per night I can visit a player and give them a random common card. All of the cards are vanilla monsters and have no effects. n1 I gave JC an Elemental HERO Sparkman n2 I gave Brandis an Insect Knight n3 I gave Audioslayne a Bokoichi the Freightening Car I mostly targeted floaters/people I didn't expect to die quickly (JC/Audio were subbed in those nights). seems ok to claim given Soph & Diana's ability flips and the fact that all three of my recipients are still alive 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
773 202 LUNA 2908 Posted October 29 On 10/25/2019 at 5:55 PM, hazmah said: To be fair, then we also have doubt with TGT/Gemstone interaction, as they both seem to be protectors. I don't think overlapping roles itself seems to be alignment-indicative, unless you think both of Tyranno and 1 of Dyachei/Woawa are definitely scum hopefully my role shows my perspective better re: two vigs Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
773 202 LUNA 2908 Posted October 29 On 10/23/2019 at 0:17 PM, JC. said: just you wait until i get clayman and polymerization ...and then keep waiting, because i am pretty sure it is going to do nothing sorry Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
»Audioslayne 917 Posted October 29 54 minutes ago, aurirevoir said: I think now is as good a time as any to claim. I am MerchBot - once per night I can visit a player and give them a random common card. All of the cards are vanilla monsters and have no effects. n1 I gave JC an Elemental HERO Sparkman n2 I gave Brandis an Insect Knight n3 I gave Audioslayne a Bokoichi the Freightening Car I mostly targeted floaters/people I didn't expect to die quickly (JC/Audio were subbed in those nights). seems ok to claim given Soph & Diana's ability flips and the fact that all three of my recipients are still alive Not sure what to make of this role (and I have no reference for the flavor of this game) but will confirm I received a Bokoichi. Just finished reading btw. Going to try to formulate my thoughts. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
+Jazz 5488 Posted October 29 Vote Count: flacko - (3) Walia, Woawa, auri Dyachei - (1) Faint Sage - (1) TGT Not Voting: (8) audio, Brandis, Dyachei, flacko, haz, JC, Moxies, Sage Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
